| Penn State | Michigan State | ||||
| QB | Derek Anderson, Oregon State | 249 | QB | Matt Leinart, USC | 355 |
| RB | Keylon Kincade, SMU | 357 | RB | David Mikell, Boise State | 738 |
| RB | Brandon Warfield, Utah | 438 | RB | DeAngelo Williams, Memphis | 515 |
| WR | Chris Pittman | 463 | WR | Mike Williams, USC | 220 |
| WR | Courtney Roby, Indiana | 100 | WR | Marque Davis, Fresno State | 19 |
| DEF | USC | 86 | DEF | Pittsburgh | -105 |
| TOTAL | 1693 | TOTAL | 1742 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated