| Ohio State | Illinois | ||||
| QB | Eli Manning, Mississippi | 714 | QB | Philip Rivers, North Carolina State | 596 |
| RB | D.D. Cox, New Mexico | 52 | RB | Greg Jones, Florida State | 101 |
| RB | Chris Douglas, Duke | 387 | RB | Fred Russell, Iowa | 242 |
| WR | Agim Shabaj, Michigan State | 286 | WR | Lee Evans, Wisconsin | 146 |
| WR | Earvin Johnson, UNLV | 227 | WR | Derrick Hamilton, Clemson | 286 |
| DEF | Bowling Green | 248 | DEF | Notre Dame | -477 |
| TOTAL | 1914 | TOTAL | 894 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated