| Ohio State | Illinois | ||||
| QB | Jason Johnson, Arizona | 84 | QB | Philip Rivers, North Carolina State | 712 |
| RB | T.A. McLendon, North Carolina State | 207 | RB | Earnest Graham, Florida | 283 |
| RB | Marcus Whalen, BYU | 403 | RB | Fred Russell, Iowa | 368 |
| WR | Kevin Curtis, Utah State | 535 | WR | -- | 0 |
| WR | Justin Colbert, Hawaii | 361 | WR | -- | 0 |
| DEF | Louisville | -147 | DEF | Notre Dame | 40 |
| TOTAL | 1443 | TOTAL | 1403 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated