| Illinois | Ohio State | ||||
| QB | Philip Rivers, North Carolina State | 348 | QB | Eli Manning, Mississippi | 296 |
| RB | Earnest Graham, Florida | 195 | RB | T.A. McLendon, North Carolina State | 374 |
| RB | Greg Jones, Florida State | 201 | RB | Marcus Whalen, BYU | 280 |
| WR | James Newson, Oregon State | 417 | WR | Jerricho Cotchery, North Carolina State | 433 |
| WR | Andre Forde, Buffalo | -- | WR | Justin Colbert, Hawaii | 597 |
| DEF | Notre Dame | 192 | DEF | Maryland | 171 |
| TOTAL | 1353 | TOTAL | 2151 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated