| Illinois | Ohio State | ||||
| QB | Woodrow Dantzler, Clemson | 906 | QB | Eli Manning, Mississippi | 408 |
| RB | Brock Forsey, Boise State | 509 | RB | Thomas Hammock, Northern Illinois | 180 |
| RB | Earnest Graham, Florida | 171 | RB | Maurice Morris, Oregon | 538 |
| WR | Roy Williams, Texas | 381 | WR | Junior Mahe, BYU | 235 |
| WR | Kevin Curtis, Utah State | 593 | WR | Donald Shoals, Tulsa | 526 |
| DEF | Memphis | -405 | DEF | Nebraska | -8 |
| TOTAL | 2155 | TOTAL | 1879 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated