| Indiana | Illinois | ||||
| QB | Eric Crouch, Nebraska | 288 | QB | Jonathan Beasley, Kansas St. | 341 |
| RB | Ray Jackson, Cincinnati | 82 | RB | Travis Minor, Florida St. | 289 |
| RB | Adam Tate, Utah | 331 | RB | Brock Forsey, Boise St. | 151 |
| WR | Justin McCareins, N. Illinois | 119 | WR | Nate Pool, Marshall | 162 |
| WR | Robert Kilow, Arkansas St. | 307 | WR | Javon Green, Colorado | 108 |
| DEF | Ohio State | -260 | DEF | Texas A&M | 509 |
| TOTAL | 867 | TOTAL | 1560 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated