| Colorado | Oklahoma | ||||
| QB | Dave Ragone, Louisville | 639 | QB | Zak Kustok, Northwestern | 370 |
| RB | LaMont Jordan, Maryland | 188 | RB | Deuce McAllister, Mississippi | 28 |
| RB | Michael Wallace, Army | 541 | RB | Emmett White, Utah St. | 666 |
| WR | Deion Branch, Louisville | 617 | WR | J.J. Moses, Iowa State | 168 |
| WR | Robert Ferguson, Texas A&M | 260 | WR | Kendall Newson, MTSU | 307 |
| DEF | Florida | 111 | DEF | Toledo | 590 |
| TOTAL | 2356 | TOTAL | 2129 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated