| Vanderbilt | Mississippi St. | ||||
| QB | Bret Engemann, BYU | -12 | QB | Quincy Carter, Georgia | 199 |
| RB | Deonce Whitaker, San Jose St. | 204 | RB | Bam McDonald, Buffalo | 107 |
| RB | Michael Bennett, Wisconsin | 936 | RB | Quentin Griffin, Oklahoma | 569 |
| WR | Marvin Minnis, Florida State | 206 | WR | Antonio Bryant, Pittsburgh | 312 |
| WR | Boo Williams, Arkansas | 27 | WR | Aaron Lockett, Kansas St. | 139 |
| DEF | Florida State | 310 | DEF | Arkansas | -89 |
| TOTAL | 1671 | TOTAL | 1237 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated