| Ohio State | Indiana | ||||
| QB | Philip Rivers, North Carolina St. | 304 | QB | Jason Thomas, UNLV | 373 |
| RB | Maurice Morris, Oregon | 556 | RB | DeShaun Foster, UCLA | 184 |
| RB | Kris Briggs, SMU | 211 | RB | Derek Watson, South Carolina | 88 |
| WR | WR | ||||
| WR | Donald Shoals, Tulsa | 136 | WR | Deion Branch, Louisville | 115 |
| DEF | Tennessee | 378 | DEF | Ohio State | 341 |
| TOTAL | 1585 | TOTAL | 1101 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated