| Illinois | Penn State | ||||
| QB | Jonathan Beasley, Kansas St. | 446 | QB | Bart Hendricks, Boise State | 482 |
| RB | Brock Forsey, Boise State | 732 | RB | Ken Simonton, Oregon State | 524 |
| RB | Tanardo Sharps, Temple | 205 | RB | Dwone Hicks, MTSU | 738 |
| WR | Nate Pool, Marshall | 183 | WR | Lee Mays, UTEP | 532 |
| WR | Javon Green, Colorado | 31 | WR | Steve Smith, Utah | 287 |
| DEF | Mississippi St. | 322 | DEF | Southern Mississippi | -243 |
| TOTAL | 1919 | TOTAL | 2320 | ||
*Numbers in red mean players score has not yet been calculated